What is Artificial Intelligence?
A recent Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) discussion paper, DP22/4: Artificial Intelligence, offered the following definition of Artificial Intelligence (AI):
‘It is generally accepted that AI is the simulation of human intelligence by machines, including the use of computer systems, which have the ability to perform tasks that demonstrate learning, decision-making, problem solving, and other tasks which previously required human intelligence. Machine learning is a sub-branch of AI.
AI, a branch of computer science, is complex and evolving in terms of its precise definition. It is broadly seen as part of a spectrum of computational and mathematical methodologies that include innovative data analytics and data modelling techniques.’
- WHAT DO FIRMS NEED TO CONSIDER?
Many PIMFA members are already using AI systems and tools in their everyday operations, and it is likely that the adoption of AI in financial services will increase rapidly over the next few years.
PIMFA firms already use AI tools for several purposes. For example, they analyse large volumes of data quickly, easily, and accurately, which enables their employees to spend more time working with and for their clients.
There are concerns that as AI becomes more advanced, it could introduce new risks, for example:
system develops biases in its decision making
leading firms to make bad decisions
rESULTING IN Poor outcomes for their clients
This is why it is essential that firms deploying AI systems have a suitably robust control framework around their AI components to keep a careful check on what they are doing.
As with any innovation, AI has the potential to make fundamental and far ranging improvements in how firms can serve their clients. However, we must ensure it is continually monitored and checked regularly to manage the risk and maximise the benefit.
- What are regulators doing?
A number of government departments are asking regulators such as the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), Bank of England (BoE), Information Commissioners Office (ICO) and Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) to publish an update on their strategic approach to AI and the steps they are taking according to the White Paper. The Secretary of State is asking for this update by 30 April 2024.
On 13 March 2024, the EU Parliament approved the EU Artificial Intelligence Act. The EU AI Act sets out a comprehensive legal framework governing AI, establishing EU-wide rules on data quality, transparency, human oversight and accountability. It features some challenging requirements, has a broad extraterritorial effect and potentially huge fines for non-compliance.
As AI reshapes financial advice, this report, produced as part of our Leading Lights Forum, examines the opportunities, risks, and practical steps firms must consider to achieve lasting success.
There has been a significant increase in the number of AI providers offering products and services to financial services firms. In response to member feedback, PIMFA has partnered with Solve Partners to develop a practical AI Vendor Due Diligence Guide which provides practical support when evaluating AI vendors.
Read the guide here
latest news
Digital Regulation Cooperation Forum Report: Consumer Interest and AI
The Digital Regulation Cooperation Forum (DRCF) has published a report examining consumers’ views on the benefits and risks of generative and agentic AI, drawing on responses to its Consumer Interest and AI Call for Input and wider research.
The paper considers the factors underpinning consumer trust in AI, including quality, transparency, human oversight and control, and considers accountability, safeguards and routes to redress.
Key findings:
- AI can amplify existing harms – and it can create new risks for consumers, including manipulation
- Consumers experience AI differently –demographics, financial pressure and other individual circumstances can influence consumer vulnerability
- AI can deliver benefits – e.g. greater accessibility, efficiency and personalisation which can enable improved consumer outcomes
- Consumer understanding of AI remains limited – consumers cannot be expected to identify and manage all AI-related risks
- Consumer trust in AI is context-dependent – consumer trust can be unstable and should not be interpreted as informed acceptance of AI or its risks
- Consumers may overestimate regulatory protections – this may increase vulnerability to harm arising from AI services
- Accountability should be shared – responsibility needs to be shared across the AI value chain and consumers should have simple and accessible routes to redress
- Audit trails and clear responsibility matter – clear responsibility and traceability are important safeguards as important as agentic AI systems expand
Access the DRCF report here
- The growing use of AI agents in finance and their potential financial-stability implications
- How access controls, monitoring and other safeguards could help manage the risks as AI agents become more capable
- At a system-wide level, widespread AI adoption could increase concentration risk with the scale if such risks unknow
FCA 2026 Annual Public Meeting: Responses to Questions
The FCA has published written responses to questions which it was unable to answer during its Annual Public Meeting (APM) last month.
The responses cover wide range of topics, e.g.:
- Consumer Duty
- AI
- anti-money laundering (AML)
- appointed representatives
- non-financial misconduct (NFM)
- the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SMCR)
- sustainable finance
- enforcement
- pensions
A recording and a full transcript are also available on the FCA website.
Read the responses here
Bank of England and FCA: Survey Results on AI and Machine Learning in UK Financial Services
The Bank of England (BoE) has published results of the fourth survey of AI and machine learning in UK financial services.
Key findings include:
- AI adoption has continued to increase, with 86% of surveyed firms now using AI
- AI agents are more widespread, with 80% of respondents having agents deployed and a further 14% planning deployment within 12 months
- No more than 9% of respondents expected that AI agents would: approve or decline customer outcomes; execute trades or place orders; initiate, execute or block payments; or change limits, thresholds and controls
- Third-party AI systems account for 39% of all reported AI systems (up from 33% in 2024) and 53% of high-materiality systems (up from 35% in 2024)
- Operational efficiency, automation and productivity were the highest-rated areas of perceived benefit from AI.
- The highest-rated areas of perceived risk to firms from AI were data protection and security, third-party and supply chain risk, and GenAI-specific risks
- Integrating AI into existing business processes and decisions and constraints imposed by legacy systems or infrastructure were the most cited non-regulatory constraints to adopting AI (23% and 22% respectively)
- For regulatory constraints, 42% of respondents cited UK data protection and privacy, and 29% cited international regulation
- Some 57% said they considered the sustainability impacts of AI use
Read the findings here
AI Readiness in Central Banks
The Bank for International Settlements has published a new report exploring AI readiness in central banks, looking at how institutions are preparing to adopt and use AI.
Read the report here
Maria Fritzsche
Senior Policy Adviser - Operational Policy, Regulation and Innovation Lead
Click to expand.
PIMFA